After meeting Robert (Bent), the guy of her dreams, Melinda (Henson) marries him, despite the warnings from her sisters that he's only interested in the money that she inherited after her mother's death, and despite the fact that he cheated on her early on in their relationship. Robert is an engineer who is unable to find work, resulting in Melinda supporting them both, and an invention that he's spent years working on has drained their finances. After losing their house due to his failures, and learning that he's cheated on her again, Melinda files for a divorce, but after Robert's invention finally makes him rich, she snaps and tries to do whatever it takes to win her former husband back.
Years after they escaped the UFO death cult that raised them, brothers Justin (Benson) and Aaron (Moorhead) return to meet with its members after receiving a cryptic message. They seek closure for their past, but instead, the brothers find themselves reconsidering their own beliefs and those of the cult when they encounter bizarre phenomena around the cult's remote camp. As it begins to appear that the cult's beliefs may have been rooted in reality all along, the brothers try to unravel the truth.
Jill (Kirke) is the personal assistant and close friend of big-time Hollywood star Heather Anderson (Kravitz), but when Anderson turns up dead in Jill's home, she's quickly named as the chief suspect by the detective investigating the case (Cho). As an actress with more than her share of rivals, enemies, fans and hangers-on, the list of murder suspects isn't a short one, and Jill sets out to perform her own investigation while the detective tries to track her down and bring her in.